Shame, guilt and the inner critic

Somatic Experiencing® and certified healing shame work, for shame that lives in your physiology, not just your thoughts. We don't try to get rid of shame. We turn toxic shame back into healthy shame, in relationship, where it was wounded.

You can name your shame, trace it back to your childhood, quote Brené Brown, and still feel it the second someone gives you a side-eye glance: your eyes drop, your throat tightens, your mind fogs, and you want to disappear. Then the critic starts in. That isn't a failure of insight. Shame is a physiological survival response to the threat of losing belonging, older than words, so it responds best to work that includes your physiology and happens in relationship.

“Shame is like the kingpin.” Brian D. Mahan, SEP, on shame's role in developmental trauma (56 sec).

I grew up in the House of Shame, halfway between the House of Blues and the House of Pancakes. Healing my own toxic shame has been the most transformative work of my life.

  • Certified Healing Shame Practitioner (Lyon/Rubin Method). I assisted Bret Lyon and Sheila Rubin for four years, then taught alongside them.
  • 20+ years as a Somatic Experiencing Practitioner, with advanced training directly with Dr. Peter A. Levine
  • Trained mental health professionals in Somatic Experiencing and in healing shame; many went on to become my clients
  • Author of I Cried All the Way to Happy Hour, endorsed by four New York Times bestselling authors

Does this sound like you? Social anxiety, people pleasing, self-sabotage

  • You walk into a room full of strangers and wish you could disappear.
  • You edit every thought, word and action before anyone else can find fault with it.
  • You say yes when you mean no, and everyone else's needs come before yours.
  • You're good at what you do, and you still wait to be found out as a fraud.
  • Things finally start going well, and somehow you undo it.
  • You can't start until you know it will be perfect, like sitting in the driveway waiting for every traffic light to turn green.
  • You feel like too much, or not enough. Sometimes in the same hour.
  • You make a mistake, and it doesn't stay a mistake. It becomes proof that something is wrong with you.
  • The voice in your head never takes a day off, and it's never on your side.

A new client once told me, “I know you're into this whole shame thing, and I don't really have any shame. I just need you to help me stop this voice in my head that's eating me alive.” That voice was the shame.

Other common signs of toxic shame
  • Shyness
  • Lack of confidence
  • Regret
  • Low self-esteem
  • Feeling defeated
  • A sense of futility
  • Fear of incompetence
  • Fear of being seen or not heard
  • Vicious cycles
  • Habituated patterns
  • Addictions
  • Self-harm
  • Eating disorders
  • Negative self-talk
  • Nausea
  • Insomnia
  • Lethargy
  • Depression
  • Immobilization
  • Trouble making and holding eye contact
  • Paranoia
  • Persecution complex

Where my own critic came from

My parents were loving, and they were perfectionists. They didn't mean to damage us; they meant to elevate us. Not a hair out of place, not a grass stain on my jeans. Somewhere in all that course-correcting, I decided there wasn't anything good about me, so I learned to police myself before anyone else could.

I became a chameleon, and later the six-foot-three wallflower. People told me I was so cool, so laid back. I was shut down.

I didn't have a word for any of it until twelve years into my practice, when I found the work of Bret Lyon and Sheila Rubin. For the first time I could see what had been running my life. Shame.

The price of shame. Monica Lewinsky, TED (2015). Plays from YouTube.

Why understanding your shame hasn't changed it

Shame is learned before you have words for it, when losing belonging feels like life or death. You can't think your way out of something your body learned before you could think. That's why the books and the insight haven't touched it.

Shame is a relational wound, and it heals in relationship. Being met, without judgment, by someone tracking your nervous system is part of the work, not a backdrop to it.

Monica Lewinsky's talk shows what shame does when it goes public. The same survival response runs in private, every time the critic speaks.

What changes when toxic shame turns back into healthy shame

Picture walking into that room full of strangers and putting out your hand. Saying no once, cleanly, without a week of rehearsal. Asking for the raise. Making a mistake and letting it be a mistake. Letting a good thing stay good.

Healthy shame doesn't disappear, and you wouldn't want it to. It keeps you kind and accountable. What changes is the voice.

The critic, now
  • I'm bad.
  • There's something wrong with me.
  • I'm broken.
  • I don't deserve.
  • I don't fit in or belong.
  • I'm unlovable.
Healthy shame
  • I'm not perfect, and it's okay.
  • I make mistakes, and I learn from them.
  • I can do bad things, but that does not make me a bad person.
  • I see the value in all parts of me.

Flawed and awesome at the same time: flawesome. Transmuting toxic shame into healthy shame restores vibrancy, self-esteem, resilience, and self-reliance.

If you grew up with a narcissist, or married one

The wound of the narcissist is all-pervasive toxic shame. The narcissism is the defense against the shame, and against the terror of being found out for not being what they're trying to present to the world. So when they do get found out, they go on a smear campaign and burn everything and everyone to the ground before seeking out new territory and a new supply of empaths.

If you were on the receiving end, much of the shame you carry was never yours. It was theirs, and you took it on as truth.

How I work with shame

  • We find where the critic's voice first came from, by what feels old and familiar, so you can feel that it was never really yours.
  • We work with the freeze shame leaves behind, a little at a time, at a pace your nervous system can take.
  • We re-member the parts of you that you had to deny or cut off in order to belong.
  • Healthy anger comes back online: your yeses and your noes.
  • Sessions are on Zoom, wherever you are.

In their words

“...just talking about shame (as in traditional therapies) does little to resolve this powerful negative emotion. I have had over 100,000 patient encounters in my career and I believe to truly heal, I completely agree with Brian's premise that the shame must be felt through the body to be processed and resolved.”

Dr. Russell Kennedy, MD, on I Cried All the Way to Happy Hour

“Brian is truly an expert and he does an amazing job of explaining trauma and shame and how it impacts the body...”

Michele, Amazon review

Toxic shame is like a festering infection that only gets worse over time.

It isn't a life sentence, and it isn't who you are. It's something that happened to you, and it can be worked with.

Individual and couples sessions, 60 or 90 minutes, on Zoom, plus a 30-minute consultation.

Not ready for a session? Two Free One-Page Practices

One of them is for your inner critic. Or start with the book: I Cried All the Way to Happy Hour

Quick Answers

What is shame?

Brian D. Mahan, SEP, describes shame as a physiological survival response to the threat of losing connection. Humans are born with a longing for belonging and a need to please, and early in life rejection, neglect, or abandonment can feel like a threat to survival, so people learn to shrink, hide, or deny parts of themselves to stay connected.

What is toxic shame?

Toxic shame is shame that has been internalized as truth about who a person is, rather than about what they did. According to Brian D. Mahan, SEP, when shame is identified with, it becomes the belief that something is wrong with you, not just your behavior.

What is the difference between guilt and shame?

Guilt is about behavior: “I did something wrong.” Toxic shame is about identity: “Something is wrong with me.” Healthy shame works like guilt. It helps people learn right from wrong, repair, and belong without believing they are bad.

Where does the inner critic come from?

According to Brian D. Mahan, SEP, the inner critic forms in childhood, when being criticized or shamed teaches a child to monitor their own thoughts, words, and actions to stay in favor with the people they depend on. It begins as protection and continues long after it is needed.

Is people pleasing a response to shame?

Often, yes. Fawning, or people pleasing, is one of five common defense responses to shame (deny, attack, fawn, retreat, self-criticize), which Brian D. Mahan, SEP, adapts from the work of Bret Lyon and Sheila Rubin. People pleasing tries to prove value and worth to avoid rejection.

Is people pleasing the fawn response, or codependency?

People pleasing is often called the fawn response. Brian D. Mahan, SEP, sees it as a defense against shame, frequently learned in childhood when being shunned or ignored taught a child they had to prove they mattered. Many people who describe themselves as codependent recognize the same pattern.

What is a shame spiral?

A shame spiral is self-criticism that feeds itself: feeling bad leads to believing you are bad, which leads to feeling worse. In the words of Brian D. Mahan, SEP, you think about everything you feel, and you feel everything you think.

Are perfectionism and self-sabotage linked to shame?

In the view of Brian D. Mahan, SEP, shame drives both. Perfectionism tries to meet everyone's expectations flawlessly to prove worth; self-sabotage follows when the underlying belief says a person doesn't deserve success or will be found out. Sliding back right after progress is often a sign of shame.

Is narcissism rooted in shame?

Brian D. Mahan, SEP, holds that the wound of the narcissist is all-pervasive toxic shame, and that narcissistic behavior is the defense against feeling that shame and against the fear of being found out.

Can somatic therapy help with shame?

Brian D. Mahan, SEP, works with shame as a physiological response, not only a thought pattern. He combines Somatic Experiencing®, a form of somatic therapy, with certified healing shame work, so clients can feel and work with the body's shame response in small doses and in relationship.

Does shame ever go away?

Healthy shame stays, and should. Toxic shame can change. Brian D. Mahan, SEP, works with shame physiologically and in relationship, using Somatic Experiencing® and healing shame work, to transmute toxic shame back into healthy shame. How sessions work

Is Brian D. Mahan trained in healing shame?

Yes. Brian D. Mahan, SEP, is a certified Healing Shame Practitioner (Lyon/Rubin Method, 2017). He assisted Bret Lyon and Sheila Rubin for four years and then taught alongside them, and he has been a Somatic Experiencing Practitioner for more than 20 years.